Black Holes | The Edge of All We Know

Looking into the Black Hole

Publication information:

Peter Galison. 2020. Black Holes | The Edge of All We Know. Edited by Chyld King, Pp. 98 min.

Abstract

Black holes stand at the limit of what we can know. The Event Horizon Telescope links observatories across the world to simulate an earth-sized telescope. With this tool the team pursues the first-ever picture of a black hole, resulting in an image seen by billions of people in April 2019. Meanwhile, Hawking and his team attack the black hole paradox at the heart of theoretical physics—Do predictive laws still function, even in these massive distortions of space and time? Weaving them together is a third strand, philosophical and exploratory using expressive animation. “Edge” is about practicing science at the highest level, a film where observation, theory, and philosophy combine to grasp these most mysterious objects.

What can black holes teach us about the boundaries of knowledge?

Sasha Viewing Equations on the Chalk Globe

Synopsis

Observation

The Event Horizon Telescope

The Event Horizon Telescope links observatories across the world to simulate an Earth-sized telescope. With this tool the team pursues the first-ever picture of a black hole, resulting in an image seen by billions of people in April 2019.

LMT at Dusk
Theory

Stephen Hawking and his Team

Hawking and his team attack the black hole paradox at the heart of theoretical physics—Do predictive laws still function, even in these massive distortions of space and time?

Stephen Hawking and Andy Strominger
Philosophy

Animating Inquiry

A philosophical and exploratory story that uses expressive animation. “Edge” is about practicing science at the highest level, a film where observation, theory, and philosophy combine to grasp these most mysterious objects.  

Orange vortex simulating a black hole

Trailer

Pariscience International Science Film Festival

Official Selection, 2021
Pariscience Laurel

InScience Film Festival Nijmegen

Official Selection, 2020
Inscience Film Festival Laurel

Jackson Wild Media Awards: Earth & Sky, Long Form

Official Selection, 2020
Jackson Wild Laurel - Edge of All We Know

CPH:DOX Copenhagen International Documentary Film Festival

Official Selection, 2020
CPH:DOX Laurel - Edge of All We Know

Bergen International Film Festival

Official Selection, 2020
Bergen International film Festival - Edge of All We Know

Academia Film Olomouc

Official Selection, 2020
AFO Laurel for Edge of All We Know

Observation

Glynnis Fawkes Observation Animation

It is interesting when observations don't conform to our standard picture of how things behave. That's when people start to look for more exotic explanations. And that's what happened with the black hole story. 

Andrea Ghez
Astrophysicist
Katie Bouman speaking

Katie Bouman on Observing a Black Hole

"No telescope actually takes a picture. What happens is, the light from the black hole travels 55 million light years and then every dish collects a single stream of the light that it sees at the same time. That’s recorded onto these hard drives. We can’t send that data over the internet because it’s way too big — [the hard drives are] sent on airplanes to a central location, where they’re computationally processed. But it’s incomplete. The process of imaging is taking the incomplete information that we get from a couple of places on our virtual telescope, and trying to fill in all the missing information to get the picture an actual Earth-sized telescope would have produced. That is a hard problem."

What Comes Next?

The Black Hole Explorer is a new mission that will discover and measure a black hole’s photon ring, capturing light that has orbited a black hole. BHEX will extend the Event Horizon Telescope into space, producing the sharpest images in the history of astronomy

The black hole's photon ring

Theory

Sasha, Hawking, Perry, and Strominger

This is why we're chasing this problem, because if information is lost, then that contradicts almost everything we know about physics. Something's gone wrong understanding how black holes work.

Sasha Haco
Theoretical Physicist
Sasha, Hawking, Perry, and Strominger

Black Hole Entropy and Soft Hair

This incredible collaboration between Sasha Haco, Stephen Hawking, Malcolm Perry, and Andrew Strominger, resulted in a paper summarizing the status of their long-term project on large diffeomorphisms, soft hair, and the quantum structure of black holes through the end of their time together. Read this paper here.


Philosophy

Black hole vortex simulation as imaged from the side

It's been a perennial question in the philosophy of science: if what we're primarily interested in are phenomena as they can be detected experimentally, how, in fact, do we come to have knowledge about unobservable entities?

Lydia Patton
Professor of Philosophy, Virginia Tech
Still of Ruth Lingford Animation from 'Edge'

History, Philosophy, and Culture at the EHT

"In the development of major technical collaborations, it is rare indeed for scientists, philosophers, historians, ethnographers, art historians, and sociologists to have the chance to think together about scientific knowledge as it unfolds. Here we have that possibility, not after the fact, but now, in the course of building instruments, observations, theories, and interpretations of black holes. We are shaping the start of this joint venture; its future to be built and written."

- Peter Galison


Film Credits

Director/Producer

Peter Galison

Editor/Co-Producer

Chyld King

In Association with Sandbox Films

Executive Producers

Greg Boustead, Jessica Harrop

Music By

Zoë Keating

Cinematographers

Stephen McCarthy, Allie Humenuk, Tim Cragg

Animators

Ruth Lingford, Momentist, Inc., Warning Office, Glynnis Fawkes

With Support from the John Templeton Foundation, Sandbox Films, Sundance Institute Documentary Film Program, with support from Science Sandbox, the Office of the Vice Provost for Research, Harvard University, and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation

Vortex simulation of a black hole