Containment

Spike field

Publication information:

Peter Galison and Robb Moss. 2015. Containment, Pp. 82 min.

Can we contain some of the deadliest, most long-lasting substances ever produced?

Nuclear waste storage containers

Synopsis

Observational Essay

Left over from the Cold War are a hundred million gallons of radioactive sludge, covering vast radioactive lands. Governments around the world, desperate to protect future generations, have begun imagining society 10,000 years from now in order to create monuments that will speak across the time.

Entry Sign: Waste Isolation Pilot Plant

Graphic Novel

Containment weaves between an uneasy present and an imaginative, troubled far future, exploring the idea that over millennia, nothing stays put

Graphic Novel: Futuristic robot emerging from the ground

Trailer

Where to Watch

Host a Screening

Contact Lukas Gianocostas to host a screening of Containment

lukas_gianocostas@fas.harvard.edu

Planeta.Doc International Film Festival

Winner, 2015
Laurel - Winner Planeta Documentary Film Festival 2015

Sheffield Doc/Fest at the Bertha Dochouse

Best Of, 2015
Laurel - Best of Sheffield Doc/Fest

Cine'Eco Environmental Film Festival

Jury Prize, 2015
Laurel - Cine'Eco Jury Prize

Full Frame Documentary Film Festival

Official Selection, 2015
Laurel - Official Selection Full Frame Documentary Film Festival

Zurich Film Festival

Official Selection, 2015
Laurel - Official Selection Zurich Film Festival

Denver Film Festival

Official Selection, 2015
Laurel - Official Selection Denver Film Festival

Margaret Mead/Imagine Science Film Festivals

Official Selection, 2015
Laurel - Official Selection Margaret Mead/Imagine Science Film Festival

Rio de Janeiro International Film Festival

Official Selection, 2015
Laurel - Official Selection Rio de Janeiro International Film Festival

Observational Essay

A man viewing nuclear waste

This place is a message... and part of a system of messages... pay attention to it!

Sending this message was important to us. We considered ourselves to be a powerful culture.

This place is not a place of honor... no highly esteemed deed is commemorated here... nothing valued is here.

What is here was dangerous and repulsive to us. This message is a warning about danger.

The danger is in a particular location... it increases towards a center... the center of danger is here... of a particular size and shape, and below us.

The danger is still present, in your time, as it was in ours.

The danger is to the body, and it can kill.

The form of the danger is an emanation of energy.

The danger is unleashed only if you substantially disturb this place physically. This place is best shunned and left uninhabited.

Proposed message to display at the site of buried nuclear waste
Sandia National Laboratories Report SAND92-1382, Expert Judgement on Markers to Deter Inadvertent Human Intrusion into the Waste Isolation Plant
Read the report here
Professor Fumihiko Imamura

Fumihiko Imamura

“High dwellings ensure the happiness of our descendants. A terrible tsunami reached this place. Never build your homes any lower than this.” 

- Stone monument warning to the future.

 

Professor Fumihiko Imamura at the Tohoku University Tsunami Engineering Laboratory Disaster Control Research Center discusses how these warnings are now often dismissed as archaic.

'Mr. S' with his cattle

We were deep into making the film when, in March 2011, the terrible triple meltdown at Fukushima Daiichi began to unfold. It was very soon clear to us that this accident, through contamination, had essentially brought radioactive waste into the land and buildings of Fukushima Prefecture and its surround. In one sense, that relation to our film is clear: the Japanese were working all-out to re-contain the waste that had escaped. This was a scenario of loss of enclosure, come to life. But other connections emerged as well. Monuments, some hundreds of years old, dot the spine of Japan, warning their futures not to build below the markers that indicated the high-water mark of an earlier tsunami. Like the American scenarists, the Japanese too experimented with handed-down stories as a way around stone markers.

 

We were less interested in re-tracing one more time the myriad decisions that affected the accident than we were in how people were coping with the waste. We followed parents and their children, plant cleanup workers, fish testers, fishermen, and many others. It was sadly only possible to bring a handful into the final film, for example, a cattle farmer high in the radioactive hills who refused to kill his cows and flee. We came to know Mr. S, an older landowner, who drove every other day to his now semi-condemned ancestral home in the radioactive hills. Mr. S. made clear to us many things not so apparent in headline-grabbing news stories: without hospitals or grocery stores, living in the affected areas became impossible.

10,000 Years

The span of human civilization

"We think of truly ancient things like the Cheops Pyramid, but that is really only a few thousand years old, and that’s still there only because it’s so large and hard to carry away. No nation state has survived more than about a thousand years. The United States is only a bit more than two centuries old. I know it seems as though it should last forever, but it won’t. Even languages don’t have a long lifespan. It’s about a thousand years."

- Greg Benford, Sci-fi writer and physicist, co-author of WIPP scenarios 

24,100 Years

Half-life of plutonium

"A lot of the questions around nuclear tend to be questions about the future. The half-life of plutonium is 24,100 years. We consider something gone after 10 half-lives, so 240,000 years."

- Allison Macfarlane, Chair, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 2012-2014

100,000,000 Gallons

Amount of radioactive sludge left over from the Cold War

Left over from the Cold War are a hundred million gallons of highly radioactive sludge, thousands of acres of radioactive land, tens of thousands of unused hot buildings, all above slowly spreading deltas of contaminated ground water. Stocked around 400 reactors (worldwide) are spent fuel assemblies, growing at a rate of 12,000 tons per year—each one radioactive enough (if unprotected) to kill a carload of people driving by it at full tilt.


Graphic Novel

Robot discovering nuclear waste
Two spacemen heading to earth

The markers were not just on the surface, but should be visible however you saw the site, from above, from aircraft or satellites, or from below, whether an underground tunnel or autonomous machines drilling deep beneath the Earth. What if robots get a virus and they no longer obey their rules? What if people looted the area just the way the pyramids have been ransacked? We were trying to do scenarios that ended with intrusion so that intrusion in fact could be avoided.  

Wendell Bell and Jon Lomberg
Thinking on scenarios of the future
Peter Kuper depiction of two figures pointing at a nuclear waste site

Peter Kuper

The graphic novel, with its sort of punctiform glimpses and almost stroboscopic image of the future, might better capture what the future is like in these scenarios than an attempt to make a kind of continuous motion, three-dimensional, real-life science-fiction film. For one thing, I wanted to get a kind of retro-futuristic view, like looking from now back at 1980 or 1990 when they were planning this, and to see backwards how the future looked. It seemed to me that graphic novels could better capture that than science fiction could. Working with a great graphic novelist like Peter Kuper, I thought we might be able to get at it.

David Lobser spike field

David Lobser

The U.S. federal government demanded, as a condition for opening the WIPP site, that plans were filed for a gigantic monument to prevent inadvertent intrusion into the waste. Roughly fifteen years after the publication of this film, when the WIPP closes, its buildings will be bulldozed and the monuments constructed. David Lobser designed animation built on the proposed monuments—which visualize the actual marker designs that the DOE panels sketched.


Film Credits

Producer/Directors

Peter Galison & Robb Moss
 

Editor/Co-Producer 

Chyld King


Cinematographers 

Hervé Cohen, Tim Cragg,
Austin DeBesche, Leonard Retel Helmrich, Stephen McCarthy


Animators 

Peter Kuper, David Lobser


Composers

Mike Einziger, Danny Bensi & Saunder Jurriaans, Tristeza


With Support From National Science Foundation,
National Endowment for the Humanities, Sundance Institute
Documentary Film Program, LEF Foundation, Film Study Center

Digging towards nuclear waste